All money toolsKeep or Replace: True Car Cost

A clearer next step

Keep the car. Or make a change?

Compare keeping your current car with a replacement, including loans, running costs, depreciation and trade equity.

1Add your numbers2Compare the result3Choose your next step

Make the numbers yours.

Enter the current car's value and loan balance, a replacement price and your cash down. Review the sample assumptions below.

Example figures are prefilled
US dollars

Used as its starting market value and the replacement trade-in allowance.

US dollars
US dollars

Before the separately entered taxes and fees.

US dollars

Cash in addition to trading in your current car.

Review the loan, running-cost and resale assumptions

These sample costs can change the comparison substantially. Replace them with quotes and your own estimates.

Keep the current car

Percent
US dollars
US dollars
US dollars
US dollars
Percent

A scenario assumption, not a resale quote.

US dollars

Keep this separate from routine maintenance.

Buy the replacement

US dollars

Enter an estimate for your location and transaction. These are financed in this scenario.

Percent
US dollars
US dollars
US dollars
US dollars
Percent

A scenario assumption, not a resale quote.

Current car: monthly cost now

$584

Loan payment, insurance, fuel, maintenance and registration

Replacement: monthly cost now

$817

Replacement adds per month

$233

Your 3-year comparison
CompareKeep current carBuy replacement
Cash outlay during period$18,368$34,418
Estimated ownership cost$15,917$31,977
Estimated car value at end$5,452$15,438
Loan balance at end$0$9,998

Ownership cost counts depreciation, interest, running costs, and the entered repair or purchase fees. It does not add loan principal a second time. Cash outlay is shown separately and includes actual modeled loan payments. Monthly costs can fall when a loan ends.

Trade equity: $3,000. Replacement loan: $22,300. The current car is traded at the value entered above; any outstanding balance is paid through the new transaction.

Keep this useful

Save your figures. Pick up here later.

Keep a dated version in your dashboard. Reopen it, adjust the inputs, and save another version to compare.

A scenario helps you compare options. Completing this review records a plan step, not a change in your financial position.

Calculation notes & sources

Monthly cash demand, cash outlay and economic ownership cost measure different things. Ownership cost includes depreciation and interest rather than counting loan principal again. Review every sample running-cost and resale assumption before using the result.

Fixed rates, monthly payments, unchanged running costs and compounded annual depreciation are assumed. No rebates, trade-in tax relief, balloon payments, sale costs or investment returns on cash are modeled.